Disease name and synonyms
Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV
Sack-Barabas syndrome
Vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome
Vascular type of Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS)
Definition
Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV, also known as the vascular type of Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS), is an inherited disorder of connective tissue characterised by severe arterial and digestive complications which are rarely, if at all, observed in the other forms EDS 12. Patients with EDS type IV, most of whom display characteristic facial features and premature ageing of limb extremities (acrogeria), are predisposed to vascular and digestive ruptures, as well as perforations of the gravid uterus. Arterial ruptures account for the majority of deaths, whilst digestive perforations, occurring mainly on the sigmoid colon, are less often fatal. These complications, rare in childhood, affect 25% of patients before the age of 20, and 80% by the age of 40 1. The median age of death is estimated to be 50 years. Due to different clinical symptoms, natural history and prognosis, EDS type IV should be assessed separately within the group of EDS.
Epidemiology
The Ehlers-Danlos syndromes are a group of hereditary disorders of connective tissue, whose prevalence is estimated between 1/10,000 and 1/25,000, with no ethnic predisposition. The Villefranche classification identifies six clinical types (Table 1) 3, among which the vascular EDS (OMIM #130050) accounts for about 5 to10% of cases 4.
<p>Table 1</p>
Classification of Ehlers-Danlos syndromes
Type
Former nosology
OMIM #
Inheritance
Gene and locus
References
Classical type
Type I
130000
ADa
COL5A1, 9q34
COL5A2, 17q21
Other?
[59, 60]
Classical type
Type II
130010
AD
COL5A1, 9q34
COL5A217q21
Other?
[59, 60]
Ehlers-Danlos like syndrome with Tenascin X deficiency
606408
ARb
TNXB, 6p21.3
[61] [62]
Hypermobility type
Type III
130020
AD
TNXB, 6p21.3
Other?
[63]
Vascular type
Type VIA
Type VIB
225400
AR
PLOD, 1p36
?
[64]
Arthrochalasia type
Types VIIA and VIIB
130060
AD
COL1A1, 17q21
COL1A2, 7q22
[65] [66]
Dermatosparaxis type
Type VIIC
225410
AR
ADAMTS2, 5q23
[67]
Progeroid type
130070
AD
XGPT1, 5q35
[68]
Periodontitis type
Type VIII
130080
AD
?, 12p13
[69]
Ehlers-Danlos variant with periventricular heterotopia
300537
XLc
FLNA, Xq28
[70]
aAD: Autosomal dominant
bAR: Autosomal resessive
cXL: X-linked
Clinical presentation
Clinical diagnosis of vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome is based on four criteria: a characteristic facial aspect (acrogeria) in most patients, thin and translucent skin with highly visible subcutaneous vessels, ecchymoses and haematomas, and arterial, digestive and obstetrical complications.
A. Facial dysmorphy
When present, acrogeria is defined by characteristic facial features such an emaciated face with prominent cheekbones and sunken cheeks. The eyes appear sunken or bulging, often with colouring around them and thin telangiectasia on the eyelids 5. The nose is pinched and thin, as are the lips, particularly the upper lip whose edges are undefined 5. A non-acrogeric form of the syndrome may also exist, whose clinical diagnosis is more difficult as several distinguishing features are not present 6.
B. Skin symptoms
In vascular EDS, the skin is abnormally thin and pale. It is smooth, soft and velvety. The veins under the skin are distinctly visible as the skin is translucent on the thorax, the shoulders and, sometimes, the abdomen. The skin on the extremities appears prematurely aged, hence the term acrogeria, and the subcutaneous veins are highly visible. We have recently shown that anteflexion of the trunk during clinical examination reveals highly visible subcutaneous vessels on the lower back. In our experience, this sign has proved highly valuable in establishing the clinical diagnosis [Germain DP, unpublished data].
However, there is no hyperelasticity of the skin in EDS type IV, in contrast to classical EDS (types I and II) and hypermobile EDS (type III) 7. Fragility of the skin may be observed, though less often than in classical EDS. This leads to wounds with an abnormally long scarring process. Secondary enlargement of scars and deposits of residual haemosiderin are typical.
C. Ecchymoses and haematomas
Ecchymoses and haematomas are common 6 and extensive bruising (Figure 1) is one of the major diagnostic criteria in the Villefranche nosology of Ehlers-Danlos syndromes 3.
<p>Figure 1</p>
Extensive bruising of the legs in a child affected with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV
Extensive bruising of the legs in a child affected with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV.
![]()
D. Complications
Patients suffering from vascular EDS are prone to arterial, digestive and obstetrical complications.
1) Vascular complications
The exact nature of the vascular lesions is disputed in the literature, as most of these correspond to arterial dissections or tears caused by the deterioration of congenitally thin and fragile tissue, leading to haematomas, false aneurysms or intracavitary bleeding. Most of the aneurysms recorded in the literature are probably 'false aneurysms', even though a percentage of patients display real fusiform aneurysms 8. Arterial ruptures or dissections are responsible for the majority of deaths as they are unpredictable 9 and because the fragility of arterial walls often makes the surgical repair difficult 10111213.
All anatomical areas can be affected, with a tendency toward arteries of large and medium calibre 14. The disease frequently involves the proximal branches of the aortic arch, the descending thoracic aorta and the abdominal aorta. The distal branches of the aorta, especially the renal, mesenteric, iliac and femoral arteries, are also particularly affected 10151617.
Dissections of the vertebral arteries and the carotids in their extra- and intra-cranial segments have been widely documented and are a typical complication of the syndrome (Figures 2, 3) 181920. Carotid-cavernous fistulae (CCF) are another typical complication of EDS type IV 2122 due to reduced content of collagen III in the arterial walls. CCF clinical diagnosis is based on the existence of tinnitus, thrill, headaches and pulsating exophthalmos 161819.
<p>Figure 2</p>
Angio-MRI (coronal section) of the supra-aortic vessels after injection of 20 cc of gadolinium in a woman aged 24 with EDS type IV, revealing a dissecting haematoma of the left internal carotid (black arrow), a bilateral dissection of the vertebral arteries in their V1 and V2 segments (white arrows) and a dissection of the middle and distal third of the right subclavian artery (head of arrow)
Angio-MRI (coronal section) of the supra-aortic vessels after injection of 20 cc of gadolinium in a woman aged 24 with EDS type IV, revealing a dissecting haematoma of the left internal carotid (black arrow), a bilateral dissection of the vertebral arteries in their V1 and V2 segments (white arrows) and a dissection of the middle and distal third of the right subclavian artery (head of arrow).
![]()
<p>Figure 3</p>
Cerebral angio-MRI after injection of 20 cc of gadolinium in a woman aged 24 with EDS type IV displaying a dissecting haematoma of the left internal carotid
Cerebral angio-MRI after injection of 20 cc of gadolinium in a woman aged 24 with EDS type IV displaying a dissecting haematoma of the left internal carotid.
![]()
EDS type IV should therefore be considered after any ischemic stroke in young subject 523. In addition, intracranial haemorrhages are found in 4% of cases, half of which are caused by the rupture of a previously-identified intracranial aneurysm 20. This prevalence appears higher than in the general population, where the frequency of unruptured aneurysms is estimated between 0.5 and 1% 19. Early diagnosis of brain haemorrhage in patients with EDS type IV is important, as it has significant implications for the care of patients and their relatives. In patients with confirmed diagnosis of vascular EDS, non-invasive techniques (echo-Doppler, angioscan, angio-MRI) are absolutely imperative for diagnosing arterial dissections or aneurysms 24. Arteriograms are associated with a high rate of complications at the point of puncture and/or tear of the arterial wall and are thus contraindicated 25. The benefit/risk ratio of any invasive diagnostic procedure should be carefully assessed and arteriogram reserved only for cases where arterial embolisation is planned 24. If thrombosis occurs after carotid or vertebral dissection, anticoagulation may be required but should be carried out with care. Surgical treatment of brain aneurysms has a high morbidity mortality rate owing to the brittle nature of the tissue in these patients. Endovascular radiology treatments also have a high post-treatment morbidity and mortality 2224.
The low instance of cerebrovascular complications does not work in favour of systematic scanning for brain aneurysms in asymptomatic patients suffering from EDS type IV, in whom the risks linked to surgery often contraindicate surgery before the appearance of symptoms 19.
There is some controversy about the usefulness of serial vascular check-up. Some experts advise against them because of the anxiety that the discovery of aneurysmal lesions (for which a treatment decision would rarely be taken) may provoke in the patients. Many authors, though, recommend carrying out an annual or biennial check-up including an ultrasound scan of the supra-aortic vessels and the arterial axes of the lower limbs, and a thoracic-abdominal scan with careful, low pressure injection 24. The discovery of a previously unknown large or rapidly-expanding aneurysm requires close monitoring. For a fortuitously-discovered vascular lesion which threatens the vital prognosis, the planned surgery is thus appropriate outside of an emergency context, even though post-operative treatments are often complicated by haemorrhages or tears of the anastomoses 8.
2) Digestive complications
Most perforations occur in the sigmoid colon 26 but the small intestine can occasionally be affected (Germain DP, unpublished data). Spontaneous ruptures of the spleen and the liver have also been described 27. There is a high risk (50%) of multiple colonic perforations and leakage from the anastomosis in case of simple segmental resection with immediate re-establishment of continuity 1228. The treatment of choice is therefore partial colectomy with colostomy, possibly followed by secondary re-establishment of continuity (Figure 4). Alternatively, total colectomy with ileostomy and closure of the rectal stump or ileo-rectal anastomosis may be proposed despite the young age of patients, because of the risk of recurrent colonic perforations and the scarcity of perforations of the small intestine 16. There is a significant risk of leakage on the anastomosis.
<p>Figure 4</p>
Surgical laparotomy scar following sigmoid colon perforation in a young patient presenting with vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome
Surgical laparotomy scar following sigmoid colon perforation in a young patient presenting with vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome.
![]()
Mortality due to digestive perforations in patients suffering from vascular EDS is relatively low, estimated at 2% 1 and, therefore, lower than some descriptions from isolated clinical cases may indicate 29.
3) Obstetrical complications
Pregnancy can increase the likelihood of a uterine or vascular rupture in women suffering from EDS type IV (particularly during the last three months) 30. Maternal mortality stands at around 12% 1531. The highest is the risk during labour, delivery and immediate post-partum period. Uterine haemorrhages occur frequently during the post-partum period and are sometimes only treatable by hysterectomy. The value of a caesarean carried out before the onset of labour (in order to minimise the risks related to contractions and take better control of haemostasis) 32 has not yet been the subject of a controlled study 24. The prophylactic use of desmopressin to control primary haemostasis has been proposed 33.
4) Pleuropulmonary complications
Pneumothoraces, haemoptysis 34 and haemorrhagic cavitary lesions 35 of the pulmonary parenchyma have occurred in several patients suffering from EDS type IV 6.
5) Mitral valve prolapse
An increased frequency of mitral valve prolapse (MVP) has been reported in patients with EDS type IV 36. However, it should be noted that this is the case in many inherited disorders of connective tissue and that the exact prevalence of MVP in the general population is unknown 7.
Aetiology
Genetics
Mode of transmission
Vascular EDS is caused by heterozygote mutations of the COL3A1 gene and is transmitted as an autosomal dominant trait 15737.
Gene location
Type III collagen is coded by an unique gene, COL3A1, whose locus is situated on the long arm of chromosome 2, in position 2q24.3-q31 38. Linkage analyses have demonstrated that vascular EDS co-segregates with polymorphic markers in this locus 39. There is no genetic heterogeneity and the polymorphic markers in the COL3A1 locus can occasionally allow the allele associated with the disease to be identified in families and can prove useful for indirect molecular diagnosis.
Physiopathology
Collagens are a family of proteins that contribute to the organisation of the extracellular matrix, comprising at least 19 proteins coded by at least 35 non-allelic genes dispersed in the genome 40. EDS type IV is caused by a deficit of type III collagen, which belongs to the fibrillar collagens. All fibrillar collagens are homo- or heterotrimerics formed by the linking of three monomers or α chains. Type III collagen is a homotrimeric formed by the linking of three α1(III) chains, with the central part of the molecule adopting a triple-helix structure. The amino acid sequence of the triple helix is characterised by repeated glycine-X-Y sequences, where X and Y are often the amino acids proline and hydroxyproline respectively. In order to ensure correct linking of α monomers, there should be no interruption in the repetition of the glycine-X-Y triplets and the length of the triple helix should remain similar for each α chain 5.
Type III collagen is a constituent of arterial walls. Its quantitative or qualitative deficit in EDS type IV accounts for the propensity of arterial tears or dissections which characterise this illness. The walls of the digestive tract are also rich in type III collagen, which explains why digestive perforations are another frequent complication of EDS type IV 4142.
Diagnosis
Clinical criteria (Table 2)
<p>Table 2</p>
Vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome: Villefranche diagnostic criteria (adapted from [3]
Major diagnosis criteria
Arterial, digestive or uterine fragility or rupture
Thin, translucent skin
Extensive bruising
Characteristic facial appearance
Minor diagnosis criteria
Positive family history, sudden death in a close relative
Acrogeria
Hypermobility of small joints
Tendon and muscle rupture
Talipes equinovarus (clubfoot)
Early onset varicose veins
Spontaneous pneumothorax or haemothorax
Diagnosis of EDS type IV is mainly clinical and is easier when the patient is acrogeric, has a positive family history or has displayed a first instance of arterial or digestive complication.
Laboratory diagnosis
1) Biochemical diagnosis
The study of the secretion of collagen III by skin fibroblasts may demonstrate a quantitative or qualitative deficit with abnormal migration of the proα1(III) chains to electrophoresis of proteins on polyacrylamide denaturant gel (Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate-Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis, SDS-PAGE) (Figure 5) 37.
<p>Figure 5</p>
Sodium dodecyl sulfate-PolyAcrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis of collagens secretion in a patient affected with vascular EDS and a control
Sodium dodecyl sulfate-PolyAcrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis of collagens secretion in a patient affected with vascular EDS and a control. The band corresponding to type III collagen is indicated by α1(III). Columns 1 and 3 correspond to the supernatant culture medium of the cutaneous fibroblasts. Colums 2 and 4 correspond to cell extracts. Secretion of type III collagen in the medium is reduced in the patient (column 1) as compared to the control (column 3). Conversely, there is intracellular retention of abnormal collagen in the cell extracts of the patient (column 2) as compared to the control. In addition, the mutant collagen III has a higher molecular weight due to additional post-translational modification α1(III)M.
![]()
2) Molecular biology
The publication of the complementary DNA (cDNA) sequence of the COL3A1 gene has paved the way towards understanding of the molecular basis of EDS type IV 434445. Direct molecular analysis, which is difficult because of the large size of the gene and the major allelic heterogeneity, allows the mutation of the COL3A1 gene to be characterised exactly (Figure 6). EDS type IV can be caused by missense point mutations affecting the glycine residues of the triple helix 46, splicing mutations with exon skipping 47, small or large deletions 44 or haploinsuffiency 48. Each mutation is particular to a given family 549.
<p>Figure 6</p>
Detection of a heterozygote missense mutation (G514V) in the COL3A1 gene in a 47-year old female patient affected with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV
Detection of a heterozygote missense mutation (G514V) in the COL3A1 gene in a 47-year old female patient affected with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV. A G to A substitution was found at nucleotide position 2042 starting from the initiation codon (ATG) of the COL3A1 gene. This nucleotide substitution alters the codon (G
T) for glycine to the codon (GTT) for valine at position 514 of the α-chain of collagen type III protein. Two electrophoregrams of the same patient are shown. (Figure courtesy of Prof. X. Jeunemaitre)
![]()
3) Histology
Optical microscopy
The observation of a skin biopsy via optical microscopy does not usually contribute a great deal but can occasionally reveal a thinned dermis, within which the groups of collagen appear sparse and/or irregular 5.
Electron microscopy
Ultrastructure study can sometimes reveal images of dilation of the granular endoplasmic reticulum of the skin fibroblasts, irregularities in the diameter of collagen fibres and an unidentified fibrino-granular substance within the extracellular matrix. Given the high number of false negatives, the absence of these images should not exclude the diagnosis EDS type IV 5.
4) Haemostasis
Haemostasis tests are normal with the possible exception of an increased bleeding time in some patients. The tendency toward haemorrhages in EDS type IV therefore appears to be due to fragility of the tissue and the capillaries, rather than a thrombocytic or plasmatic defect 50.
Differential diagnosis
In childhood, coagulation disorders and Silverman's syndrome are the most often-cited differential diagnoses, owing to the propensity for haematomas and ecchymoses in EDS type IV. In adulthood, the other Ehlers-Danlos syndromes, as well as Marfan syndrome (OMIM #154700) and Loeys-Dietz syndrome (OMIM #609192) caused by mutations in the genes TGFR1 (OMIM #190181) or TGFR2 (OMIM #190182) 5152, and arterial tortuosity syndrome (OMIM 208050) caused by a deficit in GLUT10 53 can sometimes pose a problem. Similarly, when no mutation of the COL3A1 gene has been identified, the possible existence of yet unidentified hereditary disorders of connective tissue causing arterial aneurysms or dissections, and therefore mimicking EDS type IV, should be considered. In contrast, we recently reported a syndrome of joint hyperlaxity, easy bruising, pelvic organs prolapses, premature rupture of the membranes and rectal bleeding associated with a non-glycine sequence variant of the COL3A1 gene (P435T) 54. Whether non-glycine mutations of the COL3A1 gene may be responsible for a phenotype different from EDS type IV warrants further studies 54.
Management including treatment
In the absence of specific treatment for EDS type IV, medical intervention should be focused on symptomatic treatment, prophylactic measures and genetic counselling. Patients should be advised to carry with them a letter or a card (such as the European Ehlers-Danlos syndrome passport) indicating the nature of their illness, the vascular or digestive complications to which they are at risk, their blood group and the contact details of a medical practitioner 5. Intense physical activity, scuba diving and violent sports are inadvisable. Various medications such as acetylsalicylic acid, clopidogrel and/or antivitamin K drugs interfere with platelets functions or coagulation and should therefore be avoided.
Arterial, digestive or uterine complications require immediate hospitalisation, observation in an intensive care unit and sometimes surgery 24. Arteriograms and endoscopies are contraindicated in principle. Conservative approach is usually recommended when caring for a vascular complication in a patient suffering from EDS type IV 24. When the vital prognosis is not at stake, therapeutic abstention with close monitoring is indeed preferable to unjustified surgery 24.
Surgery may, however, be required urgently to treat potentially fatal complications such as uncontrolled haemorrhage or a very large or rapidly-expanding aneurysm 824. To optimise the chances of success, the surgeon should be informed of the diagnosis before beginning surgery. Surgical precautions include delicate and atraumatic handling of tissues. The surgeon must choose the least complex and most direct repair technique possible 16. The arterial ligature is an excellent choice when it does not compromise the bloody supply of an organ 24. Simple arterial repairs have been successfully carried out in some cases 8. Serious arterial complications require arterial reconstruction with prosthetic material. Anastomoses should not be carried out with tension but strengthened by Teflon pledgets. Despite these precautions, a number of patients develop post-operative haemorrhagic complications, as well as problems relating to anastomosis of the prosthetic graft 8. At present, the information on the use of stents to treat vascular complications of EDS type IV is insufficient. The risk of arterial rupture distantly from the point of puncture is high. In all cases, it is imperative the post-operative monitoring to be prolonged and the post-operative checks by non-invasive imaging techniques (scanners) repeated 24. It is essential that patients suffering from EDS type IV are not offered surgical procedures that are unessential, such as stripping of varicose veins 455.
Pregnant women with vascular EDS should be considered at risk and receive special care 325657.
Genetic counselling
Once the diagnosis has been confirmed, the opinion of a geneticist should be sought and family screening carried out. EDS type IV is a monogenic disorder, of autosomal dominant transmission 5. Patients affected have a 50% risk of transmitting the disease to each of their children. The rate of de novo mutations is high and sporadic cases account for about half of all cases of EDS type IV. The hypothesis of recessive autosomal transmission of EDS type, still proposed in the eleventh edition of the hereditary monogenic disorders catalogue (OMIM), should be dismissed 57.
Prenatal diagnosis
Molecular prenatal diagnosis can be considered for families where the mutation is known. Choriocentesis or amniocentesis entail, in theory, risks linked to the obstetric procedure in couples where the woman suffers from EDS type IV. Artificial insemination with donor sperm (when the patient is male) and adoption are other options to discuss with the couple during genetic counselling.
Research prospects
The value of long-term beta blocker treatment (celiprolol) to prevent vascular complications in EDS type IV 58 is currently the subject of a controlled clinical trial (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00190411). However, its statistical analysis should focus on verifying the definite absence of methodological bias which the inclusion of patients with erroneous diagnosis of EDS type IV would constitute.